Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Milltown Ice Cream Depot
Welcome to Milltown Ice Cream Depot, a charming haven for dessert lovers nestled in Milltown, NJ. Located at 32 S Main St, this delightful spot has become a beloved local gem, renowned for its mouthwatering ice cream and inviting atmosphere. From the moment you arrive, the depot greets you with a friendly vibe and rich aromas of sweet treats that perfectly embody summer.
Milltown Ice Cream Depot stands out for its:
- Remarkable Variety: The menu bursts with an extensive selection of flavors to satisfy the most discerning palates. Whether you're craving something traditional like chocolate chip cookie dough or adventurous options like caramel cold brew, there's something here for everyone.
- Diversity of Choices: Catering not only to ice cream enthusiasts but also offering dairy-free and vegan options ensures that every guest can indulge guilt-free.
- Accessibility: The establishment is wheelchair accessible and offers plenty of amenities such as outdoor seating, dog-friendly options, and even catering services for those special gatherings.
- Convenient Payment Methods: With options ranging from cash to credit cards, and even cryptocurrency, paying for your sweet indulgences is seamless.
What truly makes Milltown Ice Cream Depot a standout is the dedicated staff who are ready to make your experience memorable. Many customers share heartfelt tales of friendly encounters, showcasing the warmth and enthusiasm of the crew. One satisfied patron, Adriana H., remarked on the "consistently great ice cream" and praised the "friendly workers" who add to the depot's welcoming atmosphere.
While first-time visitors might be surprised by its unassuming appearance—often called a "hole-in-the-wall"—the lively summer crowd that gathers speaks volumes. Aimee C. recounted her experience, highlighting the surprisingly delicious combination of flavors and the generous portions, making every bite worth every penny.
It’s important to note a few insights from the community. Although some patrons, like Stephanie L., have noticed a change in portion sizes and an increase in prices over the years, they still return for the delightful ice cream and agree that the flavor variety remains unparalleled.
For those looking to enjoy a sweet treat on a warm day, Milltown Ice Cream Depot is more than just a place to grab ice cream; it’s a cornerstone of the Milltown community, providing a delightful mix of flavors and memories. So grab your friends, your family, or even your furry companions, and swing by this gem for a scoop (or two!) to brighten your day!
A visit to Milltown Ice Cream Depot might just become your new favorite summer tradition—an exquisite blend of flavors, historical charm, and a delightful experience awaits!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Consistently great ice cream; been coming here for years! Friendly workers and great portions make for a bang for your buck. ”
“ Best ice cream and a wide selection of flavors. Summer nights mean a trip to Milltown Ice cream Depot! ”
“ This is a legend. Just delightful convenient walk uo window on a summer day. Great flavors high quality ”
“ This hole-in-the-wall ice cream window has been recommended to me many a times over the past few years. With the big NJ heatwave, I thought it best to give it a try now. The parking is inconspicuous and in the back shop. Make sure you dont miss it and turn into the realtor parking nextdoor. While they do have a shop, their actual store front was closed, which was a huge disappointment as we were trying to hide from the heat, but there are benches in the front of the store facing the street for some immediate seating options. The servers are your typical friendly-enough highschool/college-aged workers. They were sure to answer any questions I had and provided a requested sample, but I felt a bit disconnected and shut out from the screens and doors they are behind while you are trying to ask them questions. I get it may just be a cost-saving measure with the AC, but it made the whole interaction a bit sketchy to be honest. Oh well, all that comes with a hole-in-the-wall joint! In our urgency to escape the heat, we ended up downing the ice cream before I got pics~ I got the chocolate chip cookie dough and caramel cold brew, which was an AMAZING combo with chocolate chips in both ice cream flavors, and generous heaps of cookie dough. My friend got the cinnamon churro, and chocolate and peanut butter swirl, and he highly recommended the peanut butter swirl! Overall, they have some delicious and plentiful ice creams and they are generous with the portions here. If you are stopping by for a summer evening, I do believe its worth a try. ”
“ Been coming here for years and it's still a great place to come for ice cream. However, last time I went there was no line and portions are significantly smaller than what they use to be. They are still cash only and prices have definitely increased. Still tons of flavors to choose from, a lot of reduced fat no sugar options. They also have Italian ice and froyo. Make sure you bring your pup and get them a doggie scoop. I like how they lost the calories on the menu! ”
“ Such a cute local ice cream spot. CASH ONLY Parking in the back and behind that a little park with tables. Standard flavors and some fun ones nothing too unique. Large portion sizes. It's a walk up outdoor order only so be sure to bundle up if it's chilly and there's a line. I had the Peanut Butter Ripple (don't recommend it's mostly vanilla with little peanut butter), Starwberry (so good! With real strawberries and not too sweet), and the Butter Pecan Low Fat (tastes like the standard. This one was actually the sweetest tasting of the three and my favorite). I asked for one to go with a lid and they put it in the bag with the lid open (see photo). I mean not a problem since I checked and I'm happy about the portion but if I didn't check it would've spilled in the paper bag. ”
